Article Entry

Nook Color

The Barnes & Noble eBook Reader

Authored by
Jose Riveros
Display Face
Milibus by Ray Larabie
Text Face
FF Meta Serif Web Pro by Erik Spiekermann, Christian Schwartz and Kris Sowersby
Filed under:
Literature
Publishing
Technology

Main Content

1

The Laconic Eye

A criticism of the nookcolor is that it’s an inbetweener: a device that attempts to serve the dual purpose of being a touch tablet and an ereader. Caught in the technological purgatory between the exalted heights of Steve’s magical device upon which ethereal seraphim play Angry Birds and the earthly simulacrum of deadwood, aka the Kindle, it is claimed that the nookcolor can neither meet the needs of the avid reader addicted to the nicotine of e-ink nor the desires of the ritalin soaked electro sheep happily updating their status while downloading the latest kamasutra app. Despite this, I can state unequivocally that I have “touched the future of reading” and although that future is more akin to the foggy brim of Stieg Larsson’s rear-view mirror, the nookcolor despite its deficiencies is more than a digital curiosity. It’s a sensible bridge between the portability of the book and the always-connected umbilical to the aetheric net. Amongst similar devices, it has its place as a precursor for what may be.

nook color magazine
Apple iPad
I have tested the iPad on numerous occasions, but was never convinced that the pixel density of 132ppi was appropriate for a 10-inch screen. I will be looking forward to version two (hoping for a retina display) which is expected in early 2011.
Samsung Galaxy Tab
Much more feature rich than the nookcolor and running on Android 2.2 (Froyo) the Galaxy Tab is a non-starter at the full price ($600) and subsidized ($399). Dislike the design and I do not see having Adobe Flash installed as a plus.
Amazon Kindle
I can’t tell you the number of times I have placed the Kindle (both the rev. 3 and larger DX) in my cart only to remove it later on. At this point the Kindle seems more of an anachronism with its inefficient design, lack of touch screen and keyboard.
Sony eReader
Of the various Sony eReaders, the most compelling is the PRS-950SC Reader Daily Edition. It has all the features I would want from an e-ink display with support of the ePub open format. Still overpriced at the current $299.

2

Headphone Jacked

One of the marketed features of the nookcolor is its multimedia functionality. Loaded with a custom Android-based OS, the nookcolor ships with the Pandora streaming app and a music player. It also includes the capability to play videos in MP4 format. Although Pandora is thoughtfully implemented, by contrast, the music player is not. It functions more as a file browser than music library. Of greater concern though, is the hardware implementation of the 3.5mm headphone jack (fig. A) which does not allow the plug to sit flush against the device body. By comparison, look at the headphone jack of the iPod Nano (fig. B) which is properly designed. By allowing an eighth inch gap, less torque is required to damage the jack when the cable is accidentally pulled. Already, I have to twist the plug within the jack in order get proper contact with the left and right channels.

I should state though, that I have no intention of using the nookcolor as a multimedia device to playback video or music files. As it is, I have audiobooks saved on the microSD card. I bought this device for its principal function as an ereader. Within this context, the nookcolor is an exceptional device which satisfies most of my wants for a reading tablet: 802.11n Wifi, IPS color panel (169ppi), magazine subscriptions, web browser and small form factor (7 inch screen). Also, Barnes & Noble has promised an app store in early 2011 along with an upgrade to the OS. But, if you cannot wait that long and have a desire to use the nook color as a low cost experimental Android tablet, the device can be rooted. Doing so extends the functionality of the device and allows you to install unapproved apps including the Kindle app. With its multi-purpose use, its price ($249US) and the flexibility of purchasing content, the nookcolor was a no brainer purchase when compared to the alternative ereaders or tablets.

nook color headphone jack

3

Electro Magnetic Dreams

An additional feature of the nookcolor is the ability for its owner to make ebook purchases outside of the Barnes & Noble marketplace, including the Google ebookstore. Unlike the Amazon Kindle, the nookcolor supports the EPUB ebook standard. There is a catch, though. In order to make these third-party ebook purchases readable by the nookcolor, the user needs to download and install Adobe Digital Editions, Adobe’s flash-based ebook reader software. This application serves as the DRM gatekeeper for the publishers allowing for only six activations of devices. Once the total number of activations have been met the user is required to contact Adobe in order to reset the permitted activations. Since the application is provided by Adobe for free, Adobe makes the claim that it does not provide support, meaning if you are need of help for your purchased ebooks you are directed to a poorly maintained forum. That is if the outsourced Adobe customer service representative knows about Adobe’s ebook reader. If you are required to download and install an application at point of purchase, certainly the installation is part of the commercial transaction, thereby making the application not free. Right!?

Nevertheless, because of these draconian measures to protect the rights of publishers, and which cause injury not just to the purchaser but also the authors, I have limited my purchases of ebooks to the Barnes & Noble marketplace and the Amazon Kindle store. In both cases, my purchased content resides on each retailer’s server. The list of activated devices is provided in my account area where I have control over the number of devices or computers in use. And I am not require to seek the permission from a third-party gatekeeper like Adobe who has no interest providing support. Thankfully, there are also smaller publishers that provide their books in multiple formats, including PDF, with no DRM and which are licensed to the user not the device or computer being used to read the ebook.

When Nikola Tesla went into George Westinghouse’s office to pitch him on his latest invention (a wireless energy power device that would be installed in everyone’s home and that would power the home and potentially their cars by harnessing the freely available electro-magnetic waves emitted from the planet) and seek funding from the power company, George Westinghouse refused, stating that there would be no means to monitor customer usage, therefore, how could he charge money for its use? And in one meeting the future of the world’s dependency on fossil fuels was set in stone. Imagine our world if Westinghouse had funded Telsa’s dream.

Telcos in an effort to rein in customers offered unlimited data plans, never thinking that some of their customers would actually use such plan to, you know, download data. In response to these customer’s fair use of their plans, the Telcos have instituted metered caps to their offered plans, while in some cases, still advertising these plans as “unlimited.” Network companies in an effort to undermine the principles of the internet have attacked Network Neutrality by proposing a tiered internet payment model whereby the consumer is charged twice for the same purchase. By doing so, these companies hope to exponentially increase profits through double-dipping, therefore, stifling innovation and making what was once accessible to all, accessible only to a few.

Imagine our world if unlimited data actually meant unlimited; or if the free internet would actually mean freely accessible to all; or if publishers treated their customers like valued assets instead of thieves. Imagine a world free of DRM, free of small-time hoodlums disguised as dark-suited executives, where wireless energy cells powered our devices and where innovation wasn’t undermined, but leveraged for a greater future. Imagine such a world as you lull yourself to sleep to the pulse of electro magnetic dreams.